Advantages and Disadvantages of Segregation in Special Education; Discussed Alternative Approaches

In the United States, the education system is designed to provide opportunities for all students to succeed academically, socially, and emotionally. However, students with disabilities face unique challenges in this system. Segregation in special education is a controversial topic that has been debated for many years. Some people believe that segregating students with disabilities is necessary to provide them with the specialized support they need to succeed, while others argue that segregation can be harmful and limit opportunities for students with disabilities. This article will explore the advantages and disadvantages of segregation in special education.

What is segregation in special education?

Segregation in special education refers to the practice of separating students with disabilities from their non-disabled peers and placing them in separate classrooms, schools, or programs. This approach is often used to provide students with disabilities with specialized support and services that they may not receive in a regular education classroom.

Advantages of segregation in special education

Specialized support

One of the primary advantages of segregation in special education is the ability to provide students with disabilities with specialized support and services. In a segregated classroom, students can receive individualized attention from trained professionals who understand their unique needs and can tailor their instruction to meet those needs. This can include specialized instructional strategies, therapies, and accommodations such as assistive technology or communication devices.

Safe and comfortable environment

Segregated classrooms can provide students with disabilities with a safe and comfortable environment where they can learn and grow without the stress and anxiety of trying to keep up with their non-disabled peers. This can lead to increased self-esteem, confidence, and academic success.

Opportunities for socialization with peers with similar disabilities

Segregated classrooms can provide students with disabilities with opportunities to socialize and interact with peers who have similar disabilities. This can create a sense of belonging and community that may not be possible in a regular education classroom.

Disadvantages of segregation in special education

Limited opportunities for inclusion

One of the primary disadvantages of segregation in special education is the limited opportunities for inclusion. Segregated classrooms can isolate students with disabilities from their non-disabled peers, limiting opportunities for socialization and inclusion in regular education classrooms and activities. This can also limit their exposure to diverse perspectives and experiences.

Stigmatization

Segregation in special education can also lead to stigmatization and labeling of students with disabilities. When students are placed in separate classrooms or schools, it can create a perception that they are different or less capable than their non-disabled peers, which can lead to feelings of isolation and low self-esteem.

Lack of exposure to diverse perspectives

Segregation in special education can also limit students with disabilities’ exposure to diverse perspectives and experiences. When students are isolated from their non-disabled peers, they may not have the opportunity to learn from or interact with individuals from different backgrounds or cultures.

Alternative approaches to special education

Inclusion

Inclusion is an approach to special education that emphasizes the integration of students with disabilities into regular education classrooms and activities. Inclusion focuses on creating an environment that is accessible and accommodating to all students, regardless of their abilities or disabilities. This approach can help students with disabilities to develop social skills and relationships with their non-disabled peers, and it can also help to reduce stigma and promote understanding and acceptance of individual differences.

Co-teaching

Co-teaching is another approach to special education that involves the collaboration of a general education teacher and a special education teacher in the same classroom. This approach can provide students with disabilities with the specialized support they need while also allowing them to learn alongside their non-disabled peers. Co-teaching can also help to promote understanding and acceptance of individual differences and can lead to increased opportunities for inclusion and socialization.

Individualized Education Plans (IEPs)

Individualized Education Plans (IEPs) are legal documents that outline the individualized goals, services, and accommodations that are necessary for students with disabilities to receive an appropriate education. IEPs can be used in both segregated and inclusive settings to ensure that students with disabilities receive the support and services they need to succeed academically, socially, and emotionally.

Conclusion

Segregation in special education is a controversial topic that has both advantages and disadvantages. While segregation can provide students with disabilities with specialized support and services, it can also limit opportunities for inclusion and socialization, lead to stigmatization and labeling, and limit exposure to diverse perspectives and experiences. Alternative approaches to special education, such as inclusion, co-teaching, and individualized education plans, can provide students with disabilities with the support they need while also promoting understanding, acceptance, and inclusion of individual differences. Ultimately, the best approach to special education will depend on the individual needs and abilities of each student, and a collaborative approach between educators, parents, and students can help to ensure that all students receive the support and services they need to succeed.

Bibliography

1. Baker, E. T., & Zigmond, N. (1990). Are separate special education placements ethical? Educational Leadership, 47(5), 24-29.
2. Boyle, C., & Topping, K. J. (2018). A comparison of inclusion and special schools on the social participation of pupils with complex needs. European Journal of Special Needs Education, 33(2), 191-205.
3. Chitiyo, M., & Wheeler, J. J. (2011). Inclusion vs. segregation for students with intellectual disabilities: Educators’ perspectives. Journal of Research in Special Educational Needs, 11(3), 172-180.
4. Giangreco, M. F., Doyle, M. B., & Suter, J. C. (2010). Students with disabilities in general education classrooms: A review of the literature on peer attitudes. International Journal of Inclusive Education, 14(2), 151-167.
5. Lipsky, D. K., & Gartner, A. (1996). Inclusion and school reform: Transforming America’s classrooms. Paul H. Brookes Publishing.
6. Noddings, N. (2005). The challenge to care in schools: An alternative approach to education. Teachers College Press.
7. Ruijs, N. M., Peetsma, T. T., & Oort, F. J. (2010). The relationship between inclusive education and student well-being. Journal of School Psychology, 48(3), 331-355.
8. Salend, S. J. (2005). Creating inclusive classrooms: Effective and reflective practices. Merrill/Prentice Hall.